Method Process Safety
Venn Diagram - If you plan to carry out a HazOp study there is no need to carry out a HazID study

=Method Quiz Question 9 of 11.

If you plan to carry out a HazOp study (HS3 in the IChemE 6-stage model), there is no need to (also) carry out a HazID study (HS2 in the 6-stage model).


FALSE. Whilst HazID and HazOp studies cover similar ground, HazID uses a “top-down” approach, whilst HazOp uses a “bottom-up” approach, and these two methods often identify different issues in a design. The big advantage of HazID is that it can be carried out earlier in the project lifecycle, before full Piping & Instrumentation Diagrams (P&IDs) are available and can therefore identify safety and operability issues earlier in the project, thus saving design time, and expensive re-work later in the project.

If HazID isn’t carried out then it’s true that the HazOp may find the same issues, but the design may be too far progressed by that stage to make fundamental changes (for example, to the design basis, or to allow “inherently safer design” choices). Even if the HazID does not identify fundamental design changes, we find that the discipline of carrying out a HazID leads to a more efficient HazOp – as a rule of thumb, we find that every day spent on HazID can save up to two days of HazOp.

Go to Q10 Start again

E: T: 44 (0)1462 713313. W:

Method Functional Safety

Functional Safety + Process Safety + Cyber Security + Compliance Assessment + Competency Register + Software Solutions = Method Safety and Security

Address: Method Process Safety Ltd. Method House, Davis Crescent, Hitchin, SG5 3RB
Phone: +44 (0)1462 713313 Email: Website:

Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy. Registered In England 11410637 | VAT No. GB 302 4333 56. Site © Copyright Method Process Safety Ltd 2024

LinkedinMethod Functional Safety member of InstMC